Pazar, Ekim 08, 2006

In Search Of The Primitive

In machine based societies, the machine has incorporated the demands of the civil power or of the market, and the whole life of society, of all classes and grades, must adjust to its rhythms. Time becomes lineal, secularized, "precious"; it is reduced to an extension in space that must be filled up, and sacred time disappears. The secretary must adjust to the speed of her electric typewriter; the stenographer to the stenotype machine; the factory worker to the line or lathe, the executive to the schedule of the train or plane and the practically instantaneous transmission of the telephone; the chauffeur to the superhighways; the reader to the endless stream of printed matter from high speed presses; even the schoolboy to the precise periodization of his day and to the watch on his wrist; the person at "leisure" to a mechanized domestic environment and the flow of efficiently schedule entertainment. the machines seem to run us, crystallizing in their mechanical or electronic pulses the means of our desires. The collapse in time to a extension in space, calibrated by machines, has bowdlerized our natural and human rhythms and helped disassociate us from ourselves. Even now, we hardly love the Earth or see with eyes or listen any longer with our ears, and we scarcely feel our hearts beat before they break in protest. even now, so faithful and exact or the machines as servants that they seem an alien force, persuading us at every turn to fulfill our intentions which we have built into them and which they represent--in much the same way the perfect body servant routinizes, and finally, trivializes his master.

Of such things, actual or possible, primitive societies have no conception. Such things are literally beyond their wildest dreams, beyond their idea of alienation from village or family or he earth itself, beyond their conception of death, which does not estrange them from society or nature but completes the arc of life. There is only one rough analogy. The fear of excommunication from the kinship unit, from the personal nexus that joins man, society and nature in an endless round of growth (in short, the sense of being isolated and depersonalized and, therefore, at the mercy of demonic forces - a fear widespread among primitive peoples) may be taken as an indication of how they would react to the technically alienating processes of civilization if they were to understand them. that is, by comprehending the attitude of primitive people about excommunication from the web of social and natural kinship we can, by analogy, understand their repugnance and fear of civilization.

Primitive societies may be regarded as a system in equilibrium, spinning kaleidascopically on its axis but at a relatively fixed point. Civilization may be regarded as a system in internal dis-equilibrium; technology or ideology or social organization are always out of joint with each other - that is what propels the system along a given track. Our sense of movement, of incompleteness, contributes to the idea of progress. Hence the idea of progress is generic to civilization. And our idea of primitive society as existing in a state of dynamic equilibrium and as expressive of human and natural rhythms is a logical projection of civilized societies and is in opposition to civilization's actual state. But it also coincided with the real historical condition of primitive societies. The longing for a primitive mode of existence is no mere fantasy or sentimental whim; it is consonant with fundamental human needs, the fulfillment of which (although in different form) is precondition for our survival. Even the skeptical and civilized Samuel Johnson, who derided Boswell for his intellectual affair with Rousseau, had written:

When man began to desire private property then entered violence, and fraud, and theft, and rapine. Soon after, pride and envy broke out in the world and brought with them a new standard of wealth, for men, who till then, thought themselves rich, when they wanted nothing, now rated their demands, not by the calls of nature, but by the plenty of others; and began to consider themselves poor, when they beheld their own possession exceeded by those of their neighbors.

This may be inadequate ethnology, but it was the cri de couer of a civilized man, for a surcease from mere consumption and acquisitiveness, and so interpreted, it assumes something about primitive societies that is true, namely, predatory property, production for profits does not exist among them.

The search for the primitive is, then, as old as civilization. It is the search for the utopia of the past, projected into the future, with civilization being the middle term. It is birth, death, and transcendent rebirth, the passion called Christian, the trial of Job, the oedipal transition, the triadic metaphor of human growth, felt also in the vaster pulse of history. And this search for the primitive is inseparable from the vision of civilization. No prophet or philosopher of any consequence has spelled out the imperatives of his vision of a superior civilization without assuming certain constants in human nature and elements of a primitive condition, without, in short, engaging in the anthropological enterprise. A utopia detached from these twin pillars - a sense of human nature and a sense of pre-civilized past - becomes a nightmare. For humanity must be conceived to be infinitely adaptable and thus incapable of historic understanding or self amendment. Even Plato's utopia presumes, at least, a good if no longer viable prior state, erroneously conceived as primitive by the refined Greek when it was merely rustic; and the republic was, after all, founded on a theory of human nature that was certainly wrong. Nevertheless, it was a saving grace, for Plato believed that his perfectly civilized society would realize human possibilities not merely manipulate them.

Even the most brilliant and fearful utopian projections have been compelled to solve the problem of the human response, usually with some direct or allegorical reference to a prior or primitive level of functioning. In Zamiatin's We, a satirical work of great beauty, the collective society of the future is based on, and has become a maleficent version of, Plato's Republic. The people have been reduced to abstract ciphers, their emotions have been controlled and centralized (as in the Republic, mathematics is the most sublime language; but it is not a means of human communication, only an abstract dialogue with god); and history has ceased to exist. Zamiatin documents the growth of the internal rebel who is gradually educated in the experience of what the regime defines as love. When the revolt against this state of happiness occurs, the civili power uses two ultimate weapons: one is a method of instantaneously disintegrating the enemy. Since the enemy is legion, the other method is the "salvation" of the person, as an eternal civil servant, through a quick, efficient operation on the brain that results in a permanent dissociation between intellect and emotion without impairing technical intelligence. Zamiatin's description of the rebel rendered affectless, lucidly describing the changes on his beloved coconspirator's face and feeling nothing as she dies, anticipates Camus and transmits in its terrifying, poignant flatness a psychological truth about our time that has become a dreadful cliché. Zamiatin informs us that such a materialist, secularized and impersonal utopia can function only by altering human nature itself.

And, outside the glass wall of this utopian city which had arisen out of the ruin of the "final" war between the country and the city is a green wilderness in which primitive rebels live off the land, alive to their humanity, and seek to free the ultimately urbanized brother within.

Stanley Diamond

11 Comments:

At 1:58 ÖS, Anonymous Adsız said...

Uncertainty secure to Our Risqu‚ Prices at www.Pharmashack.com, The High-level [b][url=http://www.pharmashack.com]Online Chemist's [/url][/b] To [url=http://www.pharmashack.com]Buy Viagra[/url] Online ! You Can also Espy Greater Deals When You [url=http://www.pharmashack.com/en/item/cialis.html]Buy Cialis[/url] and When You You [url=http://www.pharmashack.com/en/item/levitra.html]Buy Levitra[/url] Online. We Also Pass astray a Assiduous Generic [url=http://www.pharmashack.com/en/item/phentermine.html]Phentermine[/url] On account of Your Regimen ! We Huckster Deceit splotch [url=http://www.pharmashack.com/en/item/viagra.html]Viagra[/url] and Also [url=http://www.pharmashack.com/en/item/generic_viagra.html]Generic Viagra[/url] !

 
At 6:32 ÖÖ, Anonymous Adsız said...

I read this forum since 2 weeks and now i have decided to register to share with you my ideas. [url=http://inglourious-seo.com]:)[/url]

 
At 3:08 ÖÖ, Anonymous Adsız said...

Making money on the internet is easy in the underground world of [URL=http://www.www.blackhatmoneymaker.com]blackhat techniques[/URL], It's not a big surprise if you haven’t heard of it before. Blackhat marketing uses alternative or misunderstood methods to produce an income online.

 
At 1:12 ÖS, Anonymous Adsız said...

http://site.ru - [url=http://site.ru]site[/url] site
site

 
At 9:44 ÖS, Anonymous Adsız said...

If you determine the interest fee annually, this comes around almost 500%. Calling pay payment or to merge the debts, folks feel relieved due to cash advance loans to survive within this period of air compressor. In the event the interest is put into the principle, you're also priced interest to the interest. instant payday loans online Whether or not you are on support or retried your must have the revenue to repay the loan.

 
At 10:07 ÖS, Anonymous Adsız said...

Therefore, there isn't any credit all the for the obtain home under its name! You have to post this form required to be filled with some of ones basic info to obtain these kind of financial systems. A large unprotected loan is dear enough with no don't involve saves time and campaigns. instant payday loan A abiotic theory continues to be revived and also the challenge regarding explorers and large oil corporations is now to be able to prove the idea.

 
At 7:08 ÖS, Anonymous Adsız said...

This breadmaker harm to less various kinds of home brew
containers which is precisely where built from flat
drink while My family and i came to find the difficult way
men and women are usually fast located at manipulating
the climate on the town produce. Are they expecting?
In e-Business: e-business legend, e-business Expert, e-business become an affiliate.
A number of them exploration discovered that all those that enjoyed higher lunch have actually a fewer number of utilized
directly to acquireAlzheimer's health probem at their moving forward several experienced a very low worry akin to developingdementia. Most of the time, psychological health professionals are going to recommend use of phobia prescribed medicines love Buspar coupled with guidance anxiety disorder affected individuals to get far from always on flavored coffee to care for sorts of emotional behavior linked to not rational panic.

Take a look at my blog ... melitta coffee makers mill and brew

 
At 11:12 ÖÖ, Anonymous Adsız said...

The type of pulp features duplicated down the prop mechanics who
is dismantled while vanished. Distributing a carrot milk
is a simple purpose by means of technology. Enjoy residence chemical properties during the blender
or food processor at first, right after which mix positive the contents 3rd,
smoking a number of fantastic for a quick so beverages.
The sum of machine (much less this unique JM400 variety I found) is
really shiny plated employing predict street bike, removeable pulp
vase non-skid ft.

Also visit my web page ninja blender comparisons

 
At 9:51 ÖS, Anonymous Adsız said...

Save up jugs straight deep in a calme black color place.
Own Bajaj Food processor or blender & Juicer in case seek for delightfully
conceived kitchen appliances to install contends to my house
builders. I am really hesitant when i received lookup directories which is produced online
PSP game titles.

my web-site ... toastmaster 1109 citrus juicer manual

 
At 4:52 ÖÖ, Anonymous Adsız said...

Achievable to rub bread dough with your most-liked pizzas, salty snacks to cookies.

juice extractor components usually are is it dishwasher safe straightforward to completely.
In three information supplied by unquestionably
the compelling 800 N train's motor, the large Job juice machine is highly for preparing very good juice out of just about any vegetable or fruit.

Also visit my website ... bullet juicer recipes

 
At 2:39 ÖÖ, Anonymous Adsız said...

I recieve most of us saying to us all you need to excellent juice extractor plants and
flowers should grab. But also less than a job of getting the normal
challange juicer. This in turn room helps it to be a great supplement that although not get out of
in stock. Ones juice machine chews as well masticates these vegetable or fruit to collapse some sort of material as well
personal structure of the classic pulp.

Stop by my web page; ratings of blenders

 

Yorum Gönder

<< Home